HudCo wrote:
up date on the gen and reg . issue got a regulator dy the way delco # 1118792 from the john deere dealer, suprising the price was about the same as all the part stores, got stopped it at the generator shop we put it on and ran it on the machine and we would have to shut it of at 16v and would just sit and motor we could tap on the reg with a screw driver and make it stop. so it whent straight back to the the john deere store another one will be here agian on monday just as well stop at the generator shop with the next one also the johndeere part said made in india on it |
Just for a heads up. I see two possibilities for what happened here.
One. On the majority of those old mechanical regulators they need to be hooked up to a good battery before they will test and work properly. Especially for the ajti motoring disconnect function to work so they don't motor on.
The reason being the relay inside the regulator for the disconnect between the ARM input and BAT output is set up with two windings that oppose each other's magnetic fields when the generator starts motoring.
The main winding is the voltage sensing one that pulls the relay contacts together when the generators output voltage is high enough to start charging the battery. The other is a current sensing coil that works as the anti motoring cut out when the current flow starts going backwards from the battery back into the generator cancels out the voltage sensing coils magnetic field causing it to release the contacts.
Without a solid circuit connection to a good properly charged battery and the generator physically connected to a sufficient mechanical load like a engine that disconnect relay can screw up and stay activated when it shouldn't be like if the battery is not taking a properly charge and the system voltage goes way high and the generator is being driven by an electric motor that has very little mechanical braking effect to make the generator draw a high current when it goes into motoring mode.
Between the two conditions it's entirely possible to produce a situation where the voltage sensing coils magnetic field will be too strong for the weaker anti motoring coil to cancel out due to there being insufficient mechanical loading to drive the anti motoring coils counter magnetic field up to a point it can cancel out the voltage sensing coil field and release the contacts. 
The other likely possibility is the regulator never got set up properly and its voltage regulation was never straight, running way too high, and the disconnect relay was set wrong as well hence needing the tap to get it to release.
To me the need to tap it suggests that either of those may have been the situation. I've seen it enough times before to know what most often causes it.
Either way a good competent service tech should have picked up on the likelihood of those possibilities right way and pulled the regulators cover off and tried adjusting things first before declaring it bad.
|